Combating food poisoning from seafood

Chocolate Slim – Lose weight and enjoy the taste

Chocolate Slim is a ground-breaking weight loss product that works as intended and has an excellent taste. This product contains cocoa, which not only brings sweet taste to a sour product but provides energy that is burned down during exercise. Try it and lose weight while enjoying this product’s exceptional taste.

Sensitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based detection of aquatic Vibrios
Validated RNRRS Output. Home List by Audience List by Topic

A rapid and highly sensitive DNA test is now available to screen seafood for bacteria. Infected seafood, particularly shellfish, can cause food poisoning. Outbreaks damage consumer confidence and producers suffer, especially the poorest. Previously, screening for bacteria was slow, taking up to 7 days, and was not always accurate. These diagnostic techniques have been extensively tested on coastal and estuarine seafood in India, Bangladesh, China, Malaysia and Japan. They’ve been used not only for detecting bacteria in seafood but also for food safety tests and for monitoring bacteria in coastal areas popular for water sports. Hundreds of laboratories have adopted these methods and they are widely accepted by international food safety authorities. They will probably become routine for ensuring that fish exports meet EU, US and Japanese import standards.

Project Ref: PHF10:
Topic: 5. Rural Development Boosters: Improved Marketing, Processing & Storage
Lead Organisation: Natural Resources Institute (NRI), UK 
Source: Post Harvest Fisheries Programme


Contents:

Description
Validation
Current Situation
Environmental Impact
Annex

Description

Research Programmes:

Post Harvest Fisheries Research Programme

Relevant Research Projects:

R5793

Partners:

  • Natural Resources Institute, Central Avenue, Chatham Maritime, KENT ME4 4TB, United Kingdom, Present contact: Dr Sue Seal (e-mail: s.e.seal@gre.ac.uk, tel: +44-1634-883602)
  • Department of Fishery Microbiology, University of Agricultural Science, Mangalore College of Fisheries, Recently renamed as Karnataka Veterinary, Animal and Fisheries Sciences University, College of Fisheries, Mangalore – 575 002, India, Contact person: Prof Iddya Karunasagar, (email:  mircen@sancharnet.in, Tel: +91-824-3330206, Fax: +91-824-436384)


Research Outputs, Problems and Solutions:

Pathogenic Vibrio bacteria are commonly found along inshore coastal and estuarine environments in Asia and can be isolated from water, sediment, plankton, fish and particularly shellfish.  Shellfish concentrate a range of Vibrio spp. through their filter feeding and as a result seafood (e.g. clams, cockles, oysters, lobsters, scallops, sardines, shrimp) is commonly contaminated with vibrios.  Human consumption of pathogenic vibrios usually gives symptoms ranging from mild gastroenteritis to severe debilitating dysentery, although for some vibrios such as Vibrio vulnificus, life-threatening septicaemia and eye, ear and wound infections can also occur especially in immuno-compromised individuals. 

Gastro-intestinal infections are usually due to consumption of raw or semi-cooked shellfish, which is popular for several types of local Asian foods.  Traditionally Vibrio spp. were detected using culture-based methods, employing enrichment media followed by isolation on selective culture media. Such culture-based methods suffer the disadvantages of being time-consuming (7 days for a positive identification) as well as cells of many Vibrio spp. entering a viable but non-culturable (VBNC) state.  As a result in the mid 1990s, the Post Harvest Fisheries Programme funded research to develop much more rapid polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based diagnostic techniques for pathogenic marine vibrios.  PCR is a technique which relies on the amplification of a nucleic-acid fragment from short DNA sequences that have been identified as pathogen-specific.  PCR techniques were developed for V. parahaemolyticusV. hollisae (reclassified as Grimontia hollisae) and V. cholerae

These PCR-based techniques were shown in 1994-1996 under R5793 to have great potential for the quick and sensitive detection and diagnosis of pathogenic Vibrios in seafood in India.  Since then, PCR-based techniques for detection and typing of Vibrio spp have been extensively validated not only within India, but also in many other countries (e.g. Bangladesh, China, Malaysia, Japan).  PCR has been found to be useful for not only typing Vibrio infections, but also real-time PCR and alkaline-phosphatase DNA probes have been found to be rapid enumeration methods for evaluation of postharvest treatments to reduce Vibrio levels in seafood.  PCR tools are also being used in selected laboratories worldwide for food safety testing, as well as monitoring the levels of pathogenic Vibrio spp. in coastal waters used for both recreational (e.g. water sports) and occupational purposes, such as fishing. 


Types of Research Output:

Product Technology Service Process or Methodology Policy Other
x x x


Major Commodities Involved:

Seafood such as oysters, shrimp, eel, cockles, crab, clams, lobsters, scallops, sardines, and squid.  The diagnostic tool outputs could be applied to other commodities that could have come into contact with contaminated seafood to assess these for the presence of pathogenic Vibrio spp.


Production Systems:

Semi-Arid High potential Hillsides Forest-Agriculture Peri-urban Land water Tropical moist forest Cross-cutting
x x


Farming Systems: 

Smallholder rainfed humid Irrigated Wetland rice based Smallholder rainfed highland Smallholder rainfed dry/cold Dualistic Coastal artisanal fishing
x


Potential for Added Value:

The RNRRS output of project R5793 was to develop PCR techniques for Vibrio parahaemolyticusV. hollisae and V. cholerae.  Since the completion of these studies there have been 100s of reports from other labs using these and other PCR-based tools for detection of pathogenic Vibrio spp. Nucleic acid diagnostic techniques were in their infancy during R5793, and recently a range of highly sophisticated PCR-based techniques have been developed with which it would make sense to cluster outputs.  These include:

  • An Alkaline Phosphatase labelled probe for the detection and enumeration of trh+ V. parahaemolyticus in seafood by the same lab as carried out R5793 research (contact Dr Karunasagar).
  • A multiplex Real-Time PCR Assay for detection of Vibrio cholerae (Dr Proll, Human Protection and Performance Division, Defence Science and Technology Organisation, Melbourne, Australia).
  • A real-time PCR test for rapid and quantitative analysis of pathogenic V. parahaemolyticus(Kehe Huang lab, College of Veterinary Medicine, Nanjing Agricultural University, China).

With regard to RNRRS funded outputs, the Vibrio PCR tests developed would have potential value for a range of other outputs dealing with the food safety and market quality of seafood products, in particular

Aquaculture and Fish Genetics Research Programme Promoting healthy peri-urban aquatic food supply,
and
Promoting networks for market quality
R8287; R8286; Prof. James Muir University of Stirling, UK
Crop Post Harvest Programme Food safety – street foods R7493, R8270, R8433, R8272 Mr K Tomlins and Dr A Graffham, Natural Resources Institute, UK

Validation

How the outputs were validated:

The research outputs are sensitive nucleic-acid based diagnostic tests for the detection of a range of pathogenic Vibrio species.  Scientific research under R5793 carried out by the Mangalore College of Fisheries (India) was used to validate these diagnostic tests and this was sufficiently rigorous to result in the following high impact peer reviewed publications.Karunasagar, I; Sugumar, G; Karunasagar, I; Reilly, PJA (1993). Rapid detection of pathogenic marine vibrios by polymerase chain reaction (PCR).  Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 53 (1993), 1615-1617

Karunasagar I, Sugumar G, Karunasagar I, Reilly A. (1995) Rapid detection of Vibrio choleraecontamination of seafood by polymerase chain reaction. Mol Mar Biol Biotechnol. 4:365-8

Karunasagar I, Sugumar G, Karunasagar I, Reilly PJ (1996) Rapid polymerase chain reaction method for detection of Kanagawa positive Vibrio parahaemolyticus in seafoods. Int J Food Microbiol. 31: 317-23

The scientific validation of the tests was done by adopting an approach of determining the sensitivity and specificity of the tests, together with ensuring they would work on seafood samples.  Detection of a mere 10 cells of the highly pathogenic Kanagawa positive strains of V. parahaemolyticus was achieved using extracts prepared directly from fish homogenates and enrichment culture in alkaline peptone water.  Similarly, V. cholerae contamination of seafood could be detected at 1000 V. cholerae/ml fish homogenate without enrichment and as few as 1-2 cells with prior enrichment in alkaline peptone water.

Since the completion of project R5793, there have been many research reports from the above, as well as other, laboratories using modifications of these and other PCR-based tools for detection of pathogenic vibrios.

Although validation was done on laboratory samples and did not result in any increases in productivity, the validation results would be most applicable to extreme vulnerable fisher communities as it is this income category that suffers most when consumer confidence in seafood safety is damaged.

Where the Outputs were Validated:

The scientific research and validation under funding from the Post Harvest Fisheries Research Programme was carried out in 1993-1996 by Prof Iddya Karunasagar’s research team at Mangalore College of Fisheries.  However, nucleic acid diagnostic techniques were in their infancy during this project (R5793), and as a result the validations that were done were limited.  In the past decade, DNA-based techniques have evolved and as a result a range of highly sophisticated similar PCR-based techniques have been developed for pathogenic vibrios not only in the above laboratory but also in institutes in the following RIUP target countries.  The institutes (with active research contact names in brackets where available) include:

Bangladesh
  • International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh, Dhaka-1212, Bangladesh (contact Drs N. Bhuiyan and G. Balakrish Nair)
China
  • College of Veterinary Medicine, Nanjing Agricultural University (Dr Kehe Huang).
  • Entry/Exit Inspection and Quarantine Bureau, Nanjing
  • Key Laboratory of Subtropical Agro-ecology, Institute of Subtropical Agriculture, the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Changsha, Hunan
  • College of Biological Science and Technology, Shenyang Agricultural University, Shenyang (Dr Shuxia Lu)
India
  • National Institute of Cholera and Enteric Diseases, Calcutta-700 010, India (Dr N. R. Chowdhury)
  • Karnataka Veterinary, Animal and Fisheries Sciences University, College of Fisheries, Mangalore ( Prof. I Karunasagar)
Malaysia
  • Faculty of Food Science and Technology (Drs LM Bilung and S. Radu)
  • Faculty of Veterinary Medicine (Dr A R Bahaman), and Faculty of Biotechnology and Biomolecular Sciences (Dr. R A Rahim and S Napis). University Putra Malaysia, 43400 UPM, Serdang, Selangor
  • Department of Molecular and Cell Biology, Biotechnology Research Institute, Universiti Malaysia Sabah, Sabah, (Dr. CV Ling)

All validations target the coastal artisanal farming systems.


Current Situation

Who are the Users?

The diagnostic tests developed through project R 5793 have been superseded and no evidence has been found of their significant use.  However, tests resulting from the improvement of R5793 tests, or of similar technologies, are being used by many research laboratories interested in food safety as well as clinical diagnostics. 

International regulatory authorities, such as the United States Food and Drug Administration (USFDA) have constructed guidelines that state seafood should contain less than 10 000 cells of V. parahaemolyticus per gram.  Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures (SPS) established in 1994 under the Uruguay Round of GATT encourage member countries to use international standards, guidelines and recommendations where they exist. 

Since the completion of R5793, laboratories in the Australia, Japan and the USA have been most active in assisting the RIUP target countries to improve their molecular diagnostic capability for pathogenic vibrio species.

PCR techniques for pathogenic vibrios are thus used to determine the presence of particular Vibriogenes in clinical samples, to monitor the spread of particular pandemics and to test the safety of retail and trade seafood samples.  The diagnostic technologies also allow the effectiveness of appropriate hygiene measures to be measured and hence assist the development of measures to avoid infected seafood contaminating other foods through contact in retail outlets.

Recently the tests have also been proposed as valuable to assist the monitoring of the safety of particular estuarine waters for recreational as well as fishing purposes.

Where the outputs have been used:

Modifications of the diagnostic tests developed are still being used actively by the Mangalore College of Fisheries (India).  Detailed investigations on the prevalence and presence of particular genotypes of both V. parahaemolyticus and V. vulnificus in oysters from the southern Indian coast have been carried out using these tests (Environmental Microbiology (2005) 7, 995-1002).  Recently, alkaline phosphatase probes have also been developed (research accepted for publication in Environmental Microbiology, 2006) to detect pathogenic vibrios in seafood.  These probes have the advantage over PCR techniques in not being affected by the presence of PCR-inhibitory compounds in seafood which can give rise to false-negative results.

The National Institute of Cholera and Enteric Diseases in Calcutta. India, is also using PCR tests to monitor the prevalence of the pandemic genotype of V. parahaemolyticus.

The International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research in Dhaka, Bangladesh, has used PCR tests for V. parahaemolyticus to determine the presence of the particularly virulent pandemic genotype in hospitalised patients, as well as toxigenic Vibrio cholerae in the aquatic environment of Mathbaria (Alam et al., (2006) Appl Environ Microbiol. 72: 2849-2855).

Various agricultural universities in China have been using PCR tests to demonstrate that retail seafood samples are commonly contaminated with V. parahaemolyticus (FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol 46 (2006) 180-186)

In Malaysia, universities (see 11) have used PCR-based tests to highlight estuarine waters that may be unsafe for recreational purposes.  PCR tests have also shown cockle samples to contain high levels of infection (62%) highlighting the risk of consumption of such seafood in an undercooked state (Bilung et al., 2005. FEMS Microbiology Letters 252: 85-88).

Scale of Current Use:

It has not been possible to obtain an accurate estimation of the current usage as the little data is available other than that published in scientific reports.  The increased prevalence of scientific papers outlining the use of the techniques for clinical diagnoses and shellfish safety analysis in 2005-2006 suggests that PCR tests for pathogenic vibrios are becoming increasingly popular for detection, enumeration and typing of Vibrio spp.  Of relevance here is that international regulatory authorities such as the USFDA now accept the application of nucleic acid tests such as PCR and probe hybridisation tests for food safety analysis. 

Considering that these nucleic acid tests are rapid, highly sensitive and specific, it appears probable that they will become increasingly popular for routine analyses in food quality control laboratories particularly to ensure that fish products for exports meet EU, US and Japanese import regulations. 

Regulations in the EU have tightened particularly in light of the first European incidence of gastroenteritis due to V. parahaemolyticus, derived from the consumption of live oysters in Spain, being reported in 2003.  There will be an increasing requirement for the rapid and accurate detection of pathogenic vibrios against a background of numerically greater numbers of non-pathogenic vibrios and other heterotrophic bacteria to prevent the emergence of seafood-associated disease outbreaks.  The non-radioactively labelled probes developed by the R5793 partner (post project funding) offer a very promising technique for such diagnostic purposes as they are less sensitive to the presence of a range of compounds present in shellfish than some of the PCR techniques.

Policy and Institutional Structures, and Key Components for Success:

Promotional activities for the diagnostic outputs outlined do not appear to be taking place.  However, International regulatory authorities such as the USFDA have indirectly assisted with the promotion of the outputs by recommending the use of non-radioactively labelled DNA probes for the enumeration of pathogenic V. parahaemolyticus to test whether shellfish to be certified meets food safety requirements. 

The new EU General Food Law which became effective in 2006 is also resulting in EU importing countries tightening their food safety legislation and demanding the adoption by exporting countries of agreed inspection, examination and certification procedures. 


Environmental Impact

Direct and Indirect Environmental Benefits:

The adoption of DNA-based diagnostic technologies assist the improvement of food quality control laboratories and the ability to meet international trade requirements regarding food safety.

Adverse Environmental Impacts:

The DNA based diagnostic tests involve the use of carcinogenic and mutagenic compounds that need to be disposed of correctly to ensure that there are no adverse environmental impacts.  Certified waste disposal systems are sometimes lacking in developing countries.

Coping with the Effects of Climate Change, or Risk from Natural Disasters:

The outputs can be used as monitoring tools to determine the changed distribution of marine Vibrios due to climate change.  For example, V. parahaemolyticus is widespread along marine coastal waters globally, with higher numbers usually encountered during warmer summer months.  A slight increase in the temperature of waters due to global warming is likely to increase the incidence of Vibrio pandemics.


Annex

EU fish import bans: the case of Uganda

Between 1996 and 2000, the EU imposed three export bans of fish from Uganda for a number of reasons.  In 1997, Spain and Italy rejected importation of fish originating from Uganda because they detected salmonella species in the imported products. In December 1997, when an EU Veterinary Inspection Mission was visiting Uganda, an outbreak of cholera was reported at some landing sites or beaches around Lake Victoria. A partial ban stopping the export of fresh-chilled fish products from Uganda was imposed.  Early in 1998, suspected incidences of fish poisoning were reported in Lake Victoria and the Uganda government imposed a temporary ban on fish exports and the decision was communicated to the EU. Despite Ugandan efforts to put in place a monitoring system to ensure that no poisoned fish ended up in the market, the EU decided to impose a ban on imports of fish originating from Lake Victoria.   

Fisheries are one of the main economic sectors in Uganda. Currently, fish exports (predominantly Nile Perch) is competing with coffee for the number one position in foreign exchange earnings.  Ugandan export earnings from fisheries have increased significantly over the past decade from US$ 1.4 mn in 1990 to almost US$40 mn in 1998 and to over US$ 100 mn in 2002. According to several studies, the Uganda fish export bans resulted in losses of over US$30 mn.  For example, UNIDO (2003) estimates that the ban of April to August 1999 alone resulted in a loss of US$36.9 million. It further estimated the loss to fishing communities in the form of reduced prices and less fishing activity at US$4.25 mn. In addition it is estimated that out of over 100,000 people who were directly employed in the fisheries sector, 32,000 people lost their jobs as a result of the ban while others earned less than one third of their average income. It is also estimated that over 300,000 people from families directly depending on fishing as a household activity were affected.

During the whole period of the ban (1997-2000), there were 11 operating fish factories in Uganda. The fish ban resulted into the closure of 3 of the 11 factories while the remaining ones had to operate at less than 20% capacity. This also resulted into factories laying off 60% to 70% of their labour force. Other auxiliary industries such as packing, the fishnet manufactures, the transport industry, the fuel industry and Uganda’s economy in general were directly affected and all the people involved suffered the direct consequences of the EU fish export ban

Considerable efforts and a variety of measures were made by Uganda to comply with international fish trade requirements; it is estimated to have increased the operating costs of fish processing plants by 50%.  In addition, costs were incurred as a result of efforts to streamline the fish inspection services and the capacity of the Department of Fisheries as the ‘Competent Authority’ (e.g. training of inspectors, provision of equipment, and introduction of a fish inspection manual).

Thus, the EU Nile perch export bans from Uganda represented major shocks for export the sector. In the short-term this led to significant loss of foreign exchange earnings, bankruptcies and unemployment, However, in the medium- to long-term, the sector appears to have recovered well, with a smaller but better equipped processing sector, improved marketing strategy, and strengthened institutions. This case study clearly demonstrates the resilience of developing countries in the face of such measures. Nevertheless, despite the notably “post-ban” recovery, there is little doubt that there are also long-term losers, perhaps through increased polarization, and particularly related to the poor and vulnerable although little information exists on the extent of this problem.


Relevant Research Projects, with links to the
Research for Development (R4D) web site
and Technical Reports:

R4D Project Title Technical Report
R5793 The development of a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) based method for the rapid and highly sensitive detection of aquatic vibrios
R7493 Enhancing the food security of the peri-urban and urban poor through improvements to the quality, safety and economics of street-vended foods.
R8270 Developing food safety strategies and procedures through reduction of food hazards in street-vended foods to improve food security for consumers, street food vendors and input suppliers
R8272 Improving food safety of informally vended foods in Southern Africa
R8286 Impact of production and marketing of freshwater aquatic products on rural livelihoods
R8287 Resource utilisation, market development and poverty targetting issues associated with emerging aquaculture in urban and peri-urban zones in sub-Saharan Africa
R8433 Maximising impact of food safety knowledge of street vended and informally vended foods generated by CPHP projects in West and Southern Africa using the coalition approach and extending the approach to India